Showing posts with label "Hey Joe". Show all posts
Showing posts with label "Hey Joe". Show all posts

Sunday, November 22, 2026

THE BYRDS' PROTO-PUNK VERSION OF A "HEY JOE"

 

“Hey Joe” is a workhorse folk-rock song that had innumerable versions recorded during the height of its 1960s popularity. Along with Wilson Pickett’s “In the Midnight Hour”, it was one of the songs of choice when a new band ran short of its own songs and needed to fill out an album that was due for release. Origin and authorship credits have been debated for decades, but it seems the song’s tale — the confession of a man on the run after shooting his unfaithful wife — inspired a generation of mostly male garage bands who were trying to emulate the misogynist swagger of the Rolling Stones. From early folk renditions to psychedelic rock and punk adaptations, each artist brought their own flavor, but few stood out in a truly distinctive way.

“Hey Joe” by the Byrds appears on their 1966 album Fifth Dimension. This song was recorded by too many bands over the decade, and there is not much difference among the 50 or so versions I’m aware of. 

But the Byrds version is unique with respect to the tempo, which is jacked to nearly punk-pogo dynamics (nearly) and David Crosby’s vocal, which is breathless and sounds winded and excited on adrenaline as would a criminal who had, as the lyrics let on, shot his wife. Forget “Everyone’s Been Burned” or “Guinevere”, the tunes of sensitive minstrel rhyming away life's ironies; “Hey Joe” is a vengeance fantasy and Crosby sounds wicked, a man who wants blood. 



The biggest payoff is Jim McGuinn’s twelve-string work, which aligns itself with that Coltrane-inspired note clustering he did for “Eight Miles High”. He riffs throughout the tune, swift, jabbing riffs, odd chord accents, more jabbing and dissonant riffing, a busy counterpoint to the pulsing bass, the earnest cowbell throughout, the bated vocalisms: this has the drama that comes at that moment when watching a two-story house on fire and the structure collapses in unredeemable sparks. This is the best version of the song ever released.

It's worth mentioning, I think, that according to the oddly dedicated site Hey Joe Versions, there are over 1,800 hundred interpretations of the revenge fantasy. That's an fact that appears to make sense when one considers the larger issue of the American infatutation with the idea that guns are a natural solution to solving most problems. But back to the Byrds...