.

It always seemed to me that all this pastiche-making was producing, at best, occasionally amusing and, more often, ugly, pointless poems, films, and artwork. The result was less a stylistic signature of intelligence than a gesture, the offhand flick of the wrist, as though the artist were too sophisticated to bother making anything that required actual decisions. Sometimes it amounted to little more than joining two things in willful defiance of whether they made aesthetic or intellectual sense. The resulting collision could be primal, cynical, even vindictive. Consider Bob Dylan singing Christmas songs. Yes, he recorded a full disc of holiday songs, Christmas in the Heart (2009) , a seasonal treat of questionable intent that seemed intent on making the most earnest Dylan loyalists apoplectic. That didn't happen, as his most die hard portions of his fan base are senior citizens who've survived too many shocks to the system in the real world to overly concern their days with the habits or motivations of a former spokesman for the Youth Movement. We seemed to have shrugged and wished him the best in our kindest thoughts. Does it make you happy, Bob. That's a good man.
The untutored avant-garde enthusiasts among us might claim genius for Dylan's scruffy vocal and compare it to the thorny rasp of the great blues singers, as though every failure to locate a melody were evidence of some higher artistic principle. The best blues singers, after all, helped redefine the modern ideal of good singing by demonstrating just how much could be accomplished outside the conventions of good singing. But I wouldn't insult an old blues singer by making the comparison. Muddy Waters, Howlin' Wolf, Bessie Smith, even that genius spawn Tom Waits, could rise above the melody line with their battered vocal equipment and give lyrics nuance, texture, and a rhythmic interplay with the instrumental arrangement. They knew what they were doing. What's most notable about Dylan's singing here, once you get past the novelty of hearing him sound like a man who has just been informed that Christmas has been canceled, is the flatness of the reading. It's grudgingly workmanlike, a sort of vocal shrug. One almost expects him to ask whether anybody has a receipt.
There isn't a traceable sense of joy or spiritual uplift. Even the comfort of ironic distancing, Brecht's alienation effect, is missing. There's little, if anything, epic about it. This is territory Dylan explored conceptually, and rather brilliantly, back in 1970 with the four sides of deliberate schlock that made up Self Portrait. The vocal affectations, orchestral arrangements, choruses, peculiar song selections, and assorted non-Dylanesque touches were all part of the operation. That was precisely the point. Dylan never seemed to have much patience for those who wanted to turn his songwriting into a religion or a political philosophy, and Self Portrait struck me as an elaborate attempt to confound the faithful. He might as well have been tossing a handful of junk mail into the congregation and watching to see whether somebody would announce that it contained a new gospel. Naturally, there were people ready to do exactly that.
I understood the joke immediately when the album came out. Unfortunately, understanding a joke doesn't necessarily make it any funnier the second, third, or fourth time around. The listening stopped being amusing long before side one was over. Self Portrait was an idea that depended almost entirely on the ironic effect it was trying to sustain, and once that effect wore off, there wasn't much left to sustain. It was a burden to listen to, a middle-of-the-road playlist masquerading as an act of conceptual sabotage. The prank did not pay dividends for anyone willing to take it seriously, although it certainly kept the Dylan interpreters employed.
It was also an entreaty to the gathered fans who regarded everything he did or didn't do, said or didn't say as a gesture signifying the movement of history. I'm not one to put words in the mouths of men and women greater than I, but I'll make an exception here. What Dylan seemed to be saying was: "Knock it off, you guys. Go home. Get a hobby. Maybe listen to somebody else for a while."
The concept hasn't aged particularly well, and repeating the gimmick here strikes me as something close to a tragedy, albeit a fairly funny one if you don't have to sit through the whole thing. It is schlock, and it doesn't matter whose name is on the label. Dylan, I suspect, is up to his old game of screwing with the heads of people who take him too seriously. He may genuinely love this tune, and he may enjoy singing it, but I still suspect there's a little mischief in the arrangement. He's throwing another wrench into the machinery that insists he must be something more than a brilliant songwriter. The trouble is that the machinery has been running so long that even a wrench doesn't stop it. Somebody will inevitably retrieve the broken parts, arrange them into a fascinating new configuration, and write a dissertation about the spiritual implications of the noise.